Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu [ Updated 2024 ]

Jersey Mike’s masterpiece that isn’t on the regular menu? Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu has been swirling around like the perfect oil and vinegar mix, and let me tell you, these hidden gems are worth the hype!

Forget boring old subs – we’re talking about meaty monsters like “The Meateor” and veggie-packed wonders like the “Greek Grilled Chicken Salad.

Jersey Mike’s specializes in serving sandwiches that are packed with a variety of meat, served with lettuce onions, tomato cheese, sauces, and cheese.

Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu

Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu

Here are some of the most popular items on the Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu:

Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo

This Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo includes a piping hot steak with grilled onions bell peppers, jalapenos that have been grilled, and mushrooms.

Price: $9.95

Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo

Then, a layer of melty gooey American cheese with chipotle mayo gives spiced-up twists on an old Philadelphia classic. This sandwich is an intriguing choice on Jersey Mike’s exclusive menu, which combines the best of both worlds.

This sandwich is a cross between two cheesesteaks: the Big Kahuna Cheesesteak and the Chipotle Cheesesteak. Combination of traditional cheesesteak, topped with Southwestern chilies and sauces.

R & R Special

R & R special sandwich from Jersey Mike’s secret menu must be on your menu. If you’re a fan of deli meats you should try it is the

R & R Special

Price: $9.95

A typical deli Reuben includes rye bread that is sandwiched with sauerkraut, corned beef, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing. However, R & R Special takes it to a whole new level.

This sandwich is made with corned brisket and pastrami, topped with melted Swiss, coleslaw, and Russian dressing. It’s a perfect mix of textures and flavors.

Jersey Mike’s uses its freshly baked white or wheat subs for this sandwich. It is filled with corned brisket and pastrami.


BLTs aren’t a rare sandwich. It’s most likely one of the most well-known sandwiches around the globe. But, if you look at the menu of Jersey Mike you won’t be able to see it on the menu.

Jersey Mike's BLT

Price: $9.95

The BLT will remain the most popular sandwich and Jersey Mike’s offers you the chance to enjoy the sandwich with a variety of amazing additions.

Jersey Mike’s can cook a great BLT even if it’s not on the menu. Add jalapenos or request chipotle mayo for some spice. For a creamy texture, add avocado.

You can request your server to add pepperoncini, onions provolone, or any other ingredient that you want.

Surf ‘n’ Turf

Jersey mike's Surf 'n' Turf

Price: $10.95

Sub-In-A-Tub is best for those who Trying to reduce the carbs. If you’re at Jersey Mike’s, you can indulge in the pleasures of a sub with no guilt by asking the server to place the ingredients in a tub, minus bread.

They will then prepare sandwiches of your choice and all the fillings inside small containers. This Jersey Mike’s menu item isn’t only perfect for cutting down on carbs but is also a gluten-free choice.



Price: $8.95

The Chick-fil-Roni is a pure delight. This sub features breaded chicken topped with grilled onions and bell peppers with melted provolone cheese. You also get a layer of fresh pepperoni and a drizzle of delicious chipotle mayo to finish it all off.

The clean taste of poultry and savory spiced ‘roni join forces to create a tasty sandwich. Adding pepperoni only enhances its appeal. Finish it off with ranch or marinara sauce, or both for a full effect.

The Meateor

The “Meateor” is a brilliant invention from the loyal Jersey Mike’s client who made this sandwich a hit via social media. In the case of eating the “Meateor,” not for vegetarians, and vegans.

Price: $13.95

The Meateor

By adding the eight varieties of meat Jersey Mike’s offers to a 6-inch roll. Request turkey, ham roast beef, pepperoni salami, prosciuttini capicola, and bacon to make sandwiches.

Add your selection of fresh vegetables as well as sauces and pickles to the list!

The Martian

Martian can be described as an Italian sandwich made with cappacuolo salami, provolone, as well as pepperoni.

The Martian

Price: $9.95

If you want to add some spice you can ask for the super-sub which includes prosciutto as well as Ham. Include lettuce, tomatoes hot peppers, and oil and vinegar to intensify the flavor.

Get the Super Sub and substitute it with salami, and prosciuttini, pepperoni, and salami. You can add some provolone if you like. This sandwich is amazing.

Meatball Supreme Pizza Sub

Jersey mike's  Meatball Supreme Pizza Sub

Price: $11.95

The meatball supreme pizza sub features grilled onions pepper, mushrooms, and onions. Then comes an abundant drizzle of the traditional red sauce and melted Provolone cheese. This sub is an absolute pleasure!

Pepperoni Pizza Sub

Pepperoni Pizza Sub

Price: $10.95

If you arrive at Jersey Mike’s and your children have a sudden urge for a pizza with pepperoni then you’re free to go anywhere. It’s because Jersey Mike’s master chefs have an answer for this – a sub for pepperoni pizza!

You place your order, telling the server to put the red sauce that you have always used on the bottom of the bread, and then top it off with pepperoni and provolone cheese.

Sweet Pepper Wrap

In addition to salads and sandwiches Jersey Mike’s menu of secrets includes a tasty wrap for you to enjoy. This one is especially for vegetarians or those who want to switch out meat in favor of vegetables throughout the rest of the day.

Price: $10.95

The sweet pepper wrap is a tasty blend of spicy and sweet flavors. It comes with a tomato-basil-flavored tortilla, white onion cherry pepper relish, grilled sweet bell peppers, lettuce, white American cheese, and chipotle mayo. You can also add mushrooms for an extra umami kick. It’s the perfect crunchy, satisfying meal to order regularly.

Lumberjack Salad

Jersey Mike’s is renowned for its tasty sandwiches, but don’t forget the secret Lumberjack Salad. It’s an enjoyable and delicious alternative to savor.

Price: $10.95

Jersey Mike’s Lumberjack Salad is a bowl version of their Club Supreme sub. It is a mixture of fresh vegetables as well as plenty of turkey, roast beef, and Applewood bacon that has been smoked and served with a spiced mustard sauce.

If you want to create a salad-like dish you could add more vegetables such as onions, peppers cucumbers, and olives as well as the drizzle of vinegar and oil.

Greek Grilled Chicken Salad

Jersey mike's Greek Grilled Chicken Salad

Price: $10.95

Do you love a good chicken Caesar wrap, but prefer to serve it in salad? Take a look at the Greek grill chicken salad! All you need to say is “One chicken Caesar wrap in a tub, please, with no Caesar dressing.”

How to Order from the Secret Menu

Ordering from the secret menu is easy. All you have to do is ask for the item by name. If the employee is not familiar with the item, you can describe it to them and they will usually be able to make it for you.


Can I customize the items on the secret menu?

Yes, you can customize the items on the secret menu to your liking.

Are the secret menu items more expensive than the regular menu items?

The prices of the secret menu items vary by location and menu item. Some items may be more expensive than the regular menu items, while others may be the same price.


  • Abigail

    Hello, I’m Abigail, an experienced content writer with three years of expertise. I specialize in providing detailed information about the delectable offerings on the Jersey Mikes Menu. Let me guide you through the tantalizing array of flavors and options available at Jersey Mikes Menu, ensuring you have the best dining experience possible.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

13 − two =